With the increasing complexity of systems and the rising number of cyber threats, in-house IT teams, particularly in small and medium-sized businesses (SMBs), are constantly bombarded with alerts from cloud services, internal security systems, and third-party security products.
This constant influx of notifications can lead to a phenomenon known as “alert fatigue,” which can significantly impact the effectiveness of cybersecurity defenses. At OSIbeyond, we have helped many of our customers understand and overcome this problem, and we want to share some key insights in this article.
The Dangers of Alert Fatigue
Alert fatigue is a psychological state in which IT professionals, especially those in cybersecurity roles, become desensitized to the constant stream of security alerts they receive daily. This desensitization can lead to a decreased response rate, increased response time, and, as a result, an overall reduction in the effectiveness of cybersecurity defenses.
The consequences of alert fatigue can be severe, as demonstrated by several real-world incidents:
- The 2013 Target security breach, which resulted in the theft of credit card credentials and personal data for an estimated 70 million customers, is believed to have been exacerbated by alert fatigue. Security analysts at Target received alerts about the presence of malware on their systems, but the sheer volume of alerts allegedly made it difficult to discern the severity of the threat, leading to a delayed response.
- Another example is the 2017 Equifax data breach, which exposed the personal information of countless Americans. Alert fatigue likely played a role in blinding security teams to critical warnings, allowing unpatched vulnerabilities within their systems to persist.
- More recently, the 2021 Colonial Pipeline ransomware attack highlighted the devastating consequences of unaddressed vulnerabilities ignored due to alert fatigue. Exploiting these vulnerabilities, hackers infiltrated the company’s systems, deploying ransomware that paralyzed the largest fuel pipeline in the US for days.
While large-scale incidents affecting prominent businesses and organizations make headlines, those who are vulnerable the most to alert fatigue are actually SMBs with limited IT resources. Unlike larger corporations that may have expansive security operations centers (SOCs) and dedicated teams for monitoring and responding to alerts, SMBs often rely on much smaller, in-house IT teams.
These teams are responsible for a wide range of duties, from daily IT support and maintenance to cybersecurity. The sheer breadth of their responsibilities, combined with relatively limited manpower, means that these teams can easily become overwhelmed.
Download
DoD Contractor’s Guide to CMMC 2.0 Compliance
Common Causes of Alert Fatigue
Alert fatigue in cybersecurity is not just an incidental issue; it’s a systemic problem with several underlying causes. By understanding these root causes, you can begin to mitigate it:
Poor Thresholds and Configuration
One of the primary causes of alert fatigue is the improper configuration of security tools and systems. When thresholds are set too low, or when the system is not fine-tuned to the specific needs of the organization, it can generate an excessive number of alerts, many of which may be false positives. Consequently, the IT team may become overwhelmed and find it more difficult to identify and respond to genuine threats.
Solution: Regularly review and adjust alert thresholds based on your organization’s risk tolerance and historical data. Fine-tune security tools to minimize false positives.
Redundant Alerts
Another common issue is the presence of redundant alerts. When multiple security tools are in use, they may generate similar or identical alerts for the same event. The duplication of alerts can significantly contribute to the overall noise and make it harder for the IT team to focus on the most critical issues.
Solution: Consolidate security tools where possible and configure them to suppress duplicate alerts. Implement a centralized alert management system to correlate and deduplicate alerts from multiple sources.
Lack of Integration and Prioritization
Many security tools and systems fail to effectively prioritize alerts based on their severity and potential impact because they operate in silos and can’t effectively correlate data from different sources. The IT team is then forced to manually investigate and respond to each alert, further increasing their workload, the potential for burnout, and the risk of failing to respond to critical alerts in a timely manner.
Solution: Invest in security tools that can integrate with each other and provide context-aware prioritization of alerts based on severity and potential impact. Implement automated workflows to streamline the alert triage process.
Inadequate Staffing and Resources
For many SMBs, the root cause of alert fatigue lies in the lack of sufficient staffing and resources dedicated to cybersecurity. When a small IT team is responsible for managing a wide range of tasks, from day-to-day IT operations to security monitoring and incident response, it can quickly become overwhelmed by the sheer volume of alerts. This can lead to decreased efficiency, increased response times, and a higher risk of overlooking critical threats.
Solution: Consider partnering with a managed security service provider (MSSP) to augment your internal IT team. MSSPs can provide 24/7 monitoring, expert analysis, and incident response capabilities, allowing your team to focus on strategic initiatives.
Outdated SIEM Technology
The limitations of outdated Security Information and Event Management (SIEM) technology also play a role in alert fatigue. Many SIEM solutions were not designed to handle the volume and complexity of data generated by modern IT environments. This can lead to a situation where security teams are inundated with alerts, many of which are false positives. Upgrading to more advanced SIEM solutions or adopting newer technologies that offer better data management and analysis capabilities can help reduce the volume of unnecessary alerts.
Solution: Evaluate your current SIEM platform and consider upgrading to a next-generation SIEM solution that can handle the volume and complexity of modern threats. Look for solutions that offer machine learning, behavioral analytics, and automated response capabilities to reduce false positives and improve efficiency.
Conclusion
Alert fatigue is a serious issue that can significantly undermine the effectiveness of cybersecurity defenses, particularly for SMBs with limited IT resources. By understanding the common causes of alert fatigue, such as poor thresholds and configuration, redundant alerts, lack of integration and prioritization, inadequate staffing and resources, and outdated SIEM technology, organizations can take proactive steps to mitigate this problem.
At OSIbeyond, we understand the challenges faced by SMBs in managing cybersecurity and dealing with alert fatigue. If you’re struggling with this problem and want to learn more about how we can help, then don’t hesitate to schedule a meeting with us today.